1909 Wheat Penny Errors, Varieties and Value

1909 is the first year of the Lincoln Wheat cent, struck at Philadelphia and San Francisco with both a VDB and a no-VDB reverse. This page covers the 1909 (Philadelphia, no VDB), 1909 VDB (Philadelphia), and 1909-S (no VDB) issues. The famous key date of the series, the 1909-S VDB, has its own dedicated guide – see How to Find a 1909-S VDB Lincoln Penny – and is not duplicated here. GetCoinHunt helps you search inventory from multiple coin dealers in one place, compare available examples, and create a wishlist alert when the right coin is not currently listed.

Design and history

Victor David Brenner designed Lincoln’s portrait for the obverse and the reverse, which frames ONE CENT and UNITED STATES OF AMERICA with two wheat ears – the design that gives the series its “Wheat cent” nickname. Brenner’s initials, V.D.B., appeared prominently along the bottom rim of the reverse on early 1909 production before public criticism led the Mint to remove them later the same year, per PCGS CoinFacts. Collectors assembling a complete 1909 set generally look for four issues: 1909 (Philadelphia, no VDB), 1909 VDB (Philadelphia), 1909-S (no VDB), and 1909-S VDB. The 1909 cent is bronze (95% copper, 5% tin and zinc), weighs approximately 3.11 grams, measures about 19mm in diameter, and has a plain edge. Philadelphia coins carry no mintmark; San Francisco coins show a small S beneath the date on the obverse.

Errors and varieties to know

The 1909 and 1909 VDB Philadelphia issues are common in absolute terms but still popular as first-year type coins. The plain 1909-S (without VDB) is a genuinely lower-mintage regular issue, though it is not as scarce or as celebrated as the 1909-S VDB. None of these three issues is a mint error – their interest comes from the VDB-reverse transition and, for the 1909-S, genuine lower mintage.

A doubled-die 1909 VDB is recognized by specialists, showing hub doubling most visible on the date and LIBERTY; it must be matched against documented reference images rather than assumed from ordinary strike doubling. Because the plain 1909-S trades for a fraction of the 1909-S VDB, added or removed VDB initials are a documented alteration risk on both San Francisco issues – see the dedicated 1909-S VDB guide for detailed authentication diagnostics on the initials and mintmark.

How to examine a 1909 Lincoln Wheat cent

Begin with the date and, on San Francisco coins, the mintmark beneath it, under one steady, directional light, then rotate the coin beneath it. Compare both sides with a problem-free example of the same date, mint, and reverse type:

• Confirm whether VDB initials are present at the bottom rim of the reverse, beneath the wheat stalks and ONE CENT – this determines which of the four 1909 issues you are examining.
• Examine the field around any VDB initials or S mintmark for seams, depressions, discoloration, or tooling marks, which can indicate initials or a mintmark were added or removed.
• True doubled-die detail is raised and rounded and repeats in documented locations; flat, shelf-like doubling is normally mechanical doubling.
• Raised lines are usually die cracks; incuse cuts are usually scratches or damage.

Weigh a candidate coin on a scale accurate to 0.01 gram and compare it against the standard 3.11-gram, 19mm, plain-edge bronze specification. Cleaning, plating, acid treatment, and vise damage are not Mint errors and reduce value even when the date and mintmark are genuine. Do not clean a candidate coin, since cleaning can obscure evidence of added or removed initials. Given the value gap between the plain 1909-S and the 1909-S VDB, certification from a major grading service is recommended for any San Francisco example presented as VDB or no-VDB.

Buying considerations

Certified versus raw coins

A certified coin has been authenticated, graded, and sealed in a holder by a third-party grading service such as PCGS or NGC. A raw coin is sold without that certification.

Before purchasing a certified coin:

• Confirm that the holder is from a recognized grading service and that the label correctly identifies the issue (1909, 1909 VDB, or 1909-S).
• Verify the certification number through the grading service’s official website.
• Compare the holder’s photographs, when available, with the coin being offered.
• Remember that counterfeit grading holders also exist.

The common 1909 and 1909 VDB Philadelphia issues are less commonly counterfeited, but the 1909-S carries more risk given its relationship to the far more valuable 1909-S VDB.

Understanding grades and condition

Wear on a Lincoln Wheat cent first appears on Lincoln’s cheekbone, jaw, hair, and coat, with the reverse showing wear on the wheat stalks and central lettering. As a bronze cent, 1909 issues can receive BN, RB, or RD color designations, with Original Red examples in Mint State commanding significant premiums.

When comparing listings, look at:

• Whether VDB initials, or their absence, are clearly photographed
• How clearly the date and mintmark are struck
• Remaining luster and color on uncirculated examples
• Whether the assigned grade is supported by a recognized grading service

Do not estimate value from a dramatic asking price. Match the precise issue, grade, and color designation to completed auction results from a source such as Heritage Auctions or Stack’s Bowers before assuming a listing reflects fair market value.

Problem coins

Watch for listings that describe cleaned, improperly cleaned, scratched, bent, damaged, corroded, environmental damage, recolored, or altered surfaces. Problem coins are sometimes placed in holders with a details grade rather than a standard numerical grade – they can be a less expensive way to own the date, but you should understand the stated problem and compare the asking price accordingly.

Suggested search terms and filters

Begin with a broad search: “1909 Lincoln cent,” “1909 VDB Lincoln cent,” “1909-S Lincoln cent,” or “1909 wheat penny.”

Then narrow the results with terms that reflect your collecting goal:

• By issue: 1909 (no VDB), 1909 VDB, 1909-S (no VDB)
• By grade: AG, G4, VG, F12, VF, XF, AU, MS
• By certification: PCGS, NGC, or “certified 1909 Lincoln cent”
• By color designation: BN, RB, RD

Useful filters may include grade, color designation, grading service, price range, dealer, certification status, and problem-free versus details-graded coins. Be careful to distinguish these three issues from the 1909-S VDB, which carries a substantially higher value.

Availability and pricing notes

Coin availability can change quickly. Listings and asking prices do not necessarily represent completed-sale values – compare multiple examples, consider each coin’s issue, grade, color, and surface quality, and review recent market information before purchasing.

GetCoinHunt does not guarantee that every listing is authentic, accurately graded, or fairly priced. Authentication, grading, pricing, return policies, and fulfillment remain the responsibility of the dealer or marketplace offering the coin.

How the GetCoinHunt wishlist alert works

1. Search for the coin. Enter “1909 Wheat Penny” to search participating dealer inventory.
2. Review the available matches. Compare listings by issue, grade, certification, color, condition, dealer, and asking price.
3. Add the search to your wishlist. If the right example is not available, save “1909 Wheat Penny” as a wishlist item. Add issue, grade, or price preferences when those options are available.
4. Get notified about new matches. When new dealer inventory matches your wishlist, GetCoinHunt sends an alert so you can review the listing before it disappears.
5. Evaluate the coin before buying. Open the dealer’s listing, verify the certification and photographs, read the complete description, and review the seller’s terms.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the 1909 and 1909 VDB cents?

Both were struck at Philadelphia the same year. The 1909 VDB carries Victor David Brenner’s initials at the bottom of the reverse; the plain 1909 does not, after the Mint removed the initials mid-year.

Is the plain 1909-S the same as the 1909-S VDB?

No. Both were struck at San Francisco, but the 1909-S VDB carries Brenner’s initials and is the famous key date of the series. The plain 1909-S lacks the initials and is considerably more available. See the dedicated 1909-S VDB guide for that issue specifically.

Are the 1909 and 1909 VDB Philadelphia cents valuable?

They are common in absolute terms but popular as first-year type coins, with Original Red uncirculated examples commanding the strongest premiums.

Is there a recognized error for 1909?

No major error is assigned to 1909 beyond the intentional VDB-reverse transition. A doubled-die 1909 VDB is recognized by specialists but must be matched against documented reference images.

What if no suitable coin is currently available?

Add “1909 Wheat Penny” to your wishlist below. You’ll be notified when newly detected dealer inventory matches your search.

Illustrated diagnostic upgrades

The following marker cards consolidate CoinHunt’s researched variety diagnostics into this canonical year guide. Each original vector is a diagnostic illustration, not a photograph, and its licensing record remains with the image asset.

1909-S Over Horizontal S Lincoln Cent

Documented Fact This San Francisco variety has a final upright S mintmark punched over remnants of an earlier S entered at a horizontal orientation. PCGS catalogs it as S/Horizontal S, and NGC lists it separately from the 1909-S/S FS-1501 variety. ^{[1] [2]}

Quick Hunt

1. Confirm a 1909 Lincoln cent with an S mintmark below the date.
2. Under magnification, inspect the metal adjoining and within the upright S for raised remnants that align with a sideways S.
3. Match the entire remnant pattern to a certified S/Horizontal S reference; one bump is not enough.
4. Exclude the separate upright S/S FS-1501 variety, mechanical doubling, damage, and an added mintmark.

Diagnostic illustration — not a photograph.

Primary Marker — Crossed Mintmark Orientations

The diagnostic is the relationship between two mintmark impressions: the dominant S is upright, while surviving portions of the earlier impression follow a roughly horizontal S beneath it. The remnants must form the same repeatable configuration seen on certified examples, not random displaced metal.

Attribution Boundary — Not FS-1501

Do not use FS-1501 as a synonym for this variety. NGC’s 1909 overview lists 1909-S/Horizontal S and 1909-S/S (FS-1501) as distinct varieties. The latter is an S over another normally oriented S; the coin on this page requires evidence of the underlying sideways punch. ^[2]

What It Is Not

• 1909-S/S FS-1501: repunching involving normally oriented S impressions, not a horizontal under-mintmark.
• Machine doubling: flat, shelf-like displacement that does not reproduce the crossed mintmark geometry.
• Contact damage or corrosion: irregular metal movement or pits without a coherent underlying S.
• Added mintmark: an altered Philadelphia cent; mintmark style, placement, and surrounding surface must be authentic.

Authentication Caution

The date is heavily counterfeited and altered. Do not authenticate it from a single apparent stroke. Compare the complete mintmark pattern and coin surfaces with certified close-ups, avoid cleaning, and obtain professional authentication before paying a substantial premium.

Image Credit

No exact forensic photograph with sufficiently clear reusable licensing was approved. CoinHunt created this original vector marker map from the cited facts. It explains the orientation relationship only and does not represent a specific die state, grade, color, or surface texture.

Looking to buy or check current prices for this coin?Search it on CoinHunt →