1924 Buffalo Nickel Errors, Varieties and Value

The 1924-S ranks among the tougher regular-issue keys of the Buffalo nickel series, and it’s frequently weakly struck to boot — a combination that makes condition and strike quality especially important when evaluating a listing for this date. GetCoinHunt helps you search inventory from multiple coin dealers in one place, compare available examples, and create a wishlist alert when the right coin is not currently listed.

Design and history

The 1924 nickel uses James Earle Fraser’s Type 2 reverse, adopted midway through 1913, with the composite Native American portrait on the obverse and a bison on a flatter, recessed reverse ground. All 1924 nickels are struck in 75% copper and 25% nickel, weigh 5.00 grams, measure 21.21mm, and have a plain edge. Philadelphia coins carry no mintmark; Denver and San Francisco pieces show a D or S beneath FIVE CENTS.

Errors and varieties to know

The 1924-S is a key regular issue and is frequently weakly struck, meaning even higher-grade examples often lack the crisp detail seen on better-struck dates. The 1924-D is also tougher than the Philadelphia issue, though not to the same degree as the S-mint coin. Strike weakness on the bison’s horn, shoulder, or mintmark on this date reflects production characteristics of the era rather than a grease-filled-die error — a distinction worth understanding before assuming a softly detailed coin is somehow defective.

No major, broadly recognized die variety is documented for 1924 in the principal references used here. Given the 1924-S’s premium, counterfeit and altered examples — particularly coins with an added S mintmark — are a documented concern, which justifies professional authentication for anything beyond a modest purchase.

How to examine a 1924 Buffalo nickel

• On a 1924-S candidate, check the S mintmark’s size, shape, and position against documented references, since added mintmarks are a real risk on this scarce, weakly struck date.
• Compare the bison’s horn and shoulder detail across several listings rather than relying on numerical grade alone — strike weakness is common enough on this date that grade and detail don’t always track together.
• Genuine doubled dies show raised, rounded secondary design in a fixed, repeatable position; flat or shelf-like doubling is mechanical, not a collectible variety.
• Raised lines across the field typically indicate die cracks; incuse marks usually point to scratches or damage.

Because the 1924-S carries a real premium, it’s worth understanding how scarce dates are sometimes altered — see our guide to documented counterfeit U.S. coins for background on detecting added mintmarks and re-engraved dates. Never clean a candidate coin before authentication.

Buying considerations

Certified versus raw coins

Given the documented counterfeit and alteration risk on the 1924-S, certification from PCGS or NGC is a sensible precaution for anything beyond the lowest grades. For an ordinary Philadelphia or Denver 1924 nickel, certification matters less at common grades.

Understanding grades and condition

Because the 1924-S is so often weakly struck, a coin’s assigned numerical grade doesn’t always tell the whole story — two coins at the same grade can show meaningfully different detail on the horn and shoulder. Compare photographs closely rather than relying on the grade number alone.

Problem coins

Cleaned, corroded, or environmentally damaged examples are common among circulated 1924 nickels, especially the S-mint issue. A details-graded 1924-S can be a more affordable way to own the key date, provided the stated problem is reflected in the price.

Suggested search terms and filters

Start broad: “1924 Buffalo nickel,” “1924-S Buffalo nickel key date,” “1924-D Buffalo nickel,” or “1924 Philadelphia nickel.”

Then narrow by:

• Mint: no mark (Philadelphia), D (Denver), or S (San Francisco)
• Strike: full strike versus typical weak strike
• Certification: PCGS, NGC, or raw

Availability and pricing notes

The Philadelphia 1924 issue is common and inexpensive. The 1924-D commands a modest premium, and the 1924-S is meaningfully scarcer still, with well-struck examples in higher grades commanding real premiums over the softly struck norm. Compare recent completed sales before assuming a listing’s asking price is representative.

GetCoinHunt does not guarantee that every listing is authentic, accurately graded, or fairly priced. Authentication, grading, pricing, return policies, and fulfillment remain the responsibility of the dealer or marketplace offering the coin.

How the GetCoinHunt wishlist alert works

1. Search for the coin. Enter “1924 Buffalo Nickel” to search participating dealer inventory.
2. Review the available matches. Compare listings by mint, strike quality, grade, and certification.
3. Add the search to your wishlist. If the right example isn’t available, save “1924 Buffalo Nickel” as a wishlist item with mint or strike preferences where available.
4. Get notified about new matches. GetCoinHunt sends an alert when new dealer inventory matches your wishlist.
5. Evaluate the coin before buying. Verify certification and photographs, read the full listing, and review the seller’s terms.

Frequently asked questions

Why is the 1924-S considered a key date?

It combines a comparatively low mintage with a strike that’s frequently weak, making sharply detailed, higher-grade examples genuinely scarce relative to demand.

Is a weakly struck 1924-S an error coin?

No. Strike weakness on the bison’s horn and shoulder is a common characteristic of this date’s dies, not a grease-filled-die or other minting error.

Is the 1924-D also scarce?

It’s tougher than the Philadelphia issue, though not as difficult to find as the 1924-S, particularly in higher grades.

Why does authentication matter for the 1924-S?

Its premium makes it a documented target for added or altered S mintmarks, so verifying the mintmark against genuine references — or buying certified — reduces the risk of an altered coin.

What if no suitable coin is currently available?

Add “1924 Buffalo Nickel” to your wishlist below. You’ll be notified when newly detected dealer inventory matches your search.

Looking to buy or check current prices for this coin?Search it on CoinHunt →